Anna Smith and her fellow students sailing the ‘Valiant Rebel’

Making mistakes: a student’s view

I was never what you would call a sporty student. I did my very best to arrange clarinet tuition in the middle of games lessons, and I was much happier in libraries, music rooms and theatres. Since then, I’ve become a fairly competent cyclist and hiker but I still retain a belief that I can’t ‘do sport’. So, it was with some trepidation that I found myself at a traditional boatyard in Norfolk, England, learning to sail on beautiful vintage wooden boats.

I had been out a couple of times on a friend’s boat, but any advantage this gave me only lasted for about half an hour. It was with the familiar sense of inferiority that I saw my fellow students apparently succeeding immediately, whilst I struggled to even grasp which direction the wind was coming from! l. By the middle of the week, I was almost ready to give up and go home. There was so much new information to process and the gap seemed too huge between where I wanted to be and where I was. At that point, I totally understood what it felt like to be the student who stops engaging with their lessons to hide the fact that they don’t feel they can do well. “Oh well”, I thought, “what did I expect? I’ve always been rubbish at this kind of thing. Why did I think this time would be different?”

“The only problem you’ve got is in your head”, said our instructor. “You don’t believe you can succeed, and you are so stressed about doing well right now that you aren’t prepared to make any mistakes. You need to focus on what you want to achieve at the end of week. If you won’t make mistakes now, you won’t improve.” Suddenly I realised that I was experiencing, from a student’s perspective, exactly the kind of thing I dealt with all the time as a History Teacher and Head of Sixth Form. I have spent hours encouraging students to try things out in their term-time history essays. I would explain that some of their attempts might result in a lower mark but that if they keep going, the risks they take will eventually result in arguments which are relevant, analytical and supported by excellent evidence (and possibly even be incisive and original).

Gordon Stobart is a keynote speaker at this year’s Cambridge Schools Conference. In his book, ‘The Expert Learner’, he challenges the myth that people are born with fixed abilities. Instead he emphasises the role of factors such as extensive practice, self-belief, and the willingness to make mistakes in the pursuit of excellence.

He says that, “For those wanting to excel, failure is an essential part of training, from which we can often learn more than from routine success” ¹. As teachers, we need to support our students in understanding this, helping them to get out of their comfort zone, not so far that they panic, but enough that they are able to make progress. Stobart calls this the Learning Zone ², and encourages us to create “a culture in which getting something wrong is seen as productive rather than a humiliation ³.’’ The more that we help our students to develop the confidence to persevere, to be willing to make mistakes, and to be reflective enough to learn from these, the more we can help them to make progress.

Anna with the ‘Valiant Rebel’For me, a mixture of fear of failure and a lack of belief in myself was holding me back. However, here I was with instructors who had faith in me, and helped me to realise that the only thing stopping me succeed was my lack of confidence. Once they had helped me to realise this, I was able to respond to their coaching, to try things out, to make mistakes, and to improve. At the end of the week, we all passed the course, and all six of us are now impatient to get back on the water, to practise, to challenge ourselves and to learn more.

This is so often the same for our students. Sometimes they have grown up being made to believe that they don’t have the ability to succeed in a particular area. As teachers, we can encourage students to persevere and be prepared to make mistakes. We can coach them in the skills they need to achieve so much more than they thought possible.

I am reminded of a postcard I used to have in my office and which I showed students who were feeling demoralised by a setback. It said simply, “I’ve learnt so much from my mistakes, I’m thinking of making a few more.” I think I need to find it and put it on my fridge, to remind myself of this wisdom next time I‘m tempted to give in.

¹ Stobart, Gordon, The Expert Learner, Challenging the Myth of Ability, Open University Press, McGraw Hill, Maidenhead, 2014 p50
² Stobart, Gordon, The Expert Learner, Challenging the Myth of Ability, Open University Press, McGraw Hill, Maidenhead, 2014 p51
³ Stobart, Gordon, The Expert Learner, Challenging the Myth of Ability, Open University Press, McGraw Hill, Maidenhead, 2014 p161

Anna took an RYA Level 1 and 2 sailing course at Hunter’s Yard, Ludham, Norfolk. She is grateful to them not only for permission to use pictures of their boats but for making her put into practice as a learner what she is always saying as a teacher.

Share this

View comments

  1. Anna, i agree with your heart to heart here. I am in the same boat. I learn from my mistakes. but you will agree with me that generally, in our society it is not something that is appreciated. Mistakes is attached with the sense of failure that if you yourself do not have, people around you specially your bosses will make you feel it. It is the environment that is generated by the department head that makes you develop a mind set where mistakes are not failures but are points where you have to stop and reflect on it and do the amendments and then then continue.

  2. I don’t think that feeling of fear let the students learn and grow happily. As a students I had always been more happier in the class where I could make the mistakes but given positive support to rectify my work. In that way I became more confident about working during that particular subject’s period.

  3. Fab photos, they are a nauatrl’ in front of the camera, you’d never believe they found it hard. But a lot of that is due to you- great at putting people at ease.Refreshing and totally nauatrl images.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related posts